The thrill of being wrong: Learning something

I am not a redbud

When we moved into this house in January 2004, this tree was a short little fellow. The photograph below is November 2003, when we began looking at the house as it was under renovation. You can make out this tree as the tiny little stick with no leaves, just to the right of the window, barely visible through the magnolia leaves. (Note: not to be confused with the taller stick at the bottom of the picture, where as he was wont to do with everything, Will left his shovel sticking in the ground.)

Taylor Hill Cottage 2003

The first year it bloomed, my friend told me it was a redbud tree. Not being from Mississippi but from dry northwest Texas, I had no frame of reference and never questioned it. A few weeks ago, when I posted signs of spring, Katie asked if it was a maple. I responded with what I had been told: redbud. When I began looking, although when it first began to bud out it seemed similar enough to pictures of redbud trees, the more this tree cycled, I was questioning that. (Thank you Katie! I am always willing to admit I am wrong, or might be wrong. I hope it makes up for other traits that may not always be my best side.)

As time passed and I watched the cycles from bud to bloom to fruit to leaves, that part of me that hungers to understand what I do not kept thinking: is that really a redbud? I kept looking at photographs, and searching Mississippi trees and coming up with zero. Yesterday, I located a site from Mississippi State University that was a supplement for tree identification: bark, leaves, stems, buds, flowers, fruit. I carefully examined the leaves that were now clearly defined and began to search the text. Voila! Right there under species of maple: the boxelder maple. The accompanying photographs convinced me this is a boxelder, a rapidly growing species often found in Mississippi. From there, it was simple to find pictures that confirmed it.

While I am cautious to a fault when posting, I have been known to err. I am also quick–once I know, to correct said errors. I think of it as evidence of the developmental model: development never ceases as long as we are open to examining our thinking.

This entry was posted in Ecosystem, Mississippi and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to The thrill of being wrong: Learning something

  1. peggy says:

    It can be hard to identfy trees – don’t beat yourself up, because the tree is a maple. We all make mistakes and that is how we learn even when we are older. I learn something new quiet often.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: The thrill of being wrong: Learning something β€” Suzassippi’s Lottabusha County Chronicles | Ups Downs Family History

  3. Wow! What a good sleuth you are!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Betty says:

    So, I am wondering what are the differences between a Redbud and a Boxelder Maple. Also, are they both native to Mississippi? It’s always good to learn. Enjoy your Monday!


    • Suzassippi says:

      Both are considered native to Mississippi. The boxelder is native North America, ranging as far north as Canada, and generally in the eastern portion of the US. The redbud is found mostly in the southeastern portion of the US. The boxelder can reach greater height, whereas the redbud is generally shorter. Although the first buds and early blooms look similar, as the stages evolve, the redbud flowers and seed pods are larger. The leaves are shaped differently. They are members of different tree families.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Katie says:

    It’s a beautiful tree, either way. πŸ™‚ I love that you tracked it down, though!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. You just never know… I have quite a few Box Elders on the farm but no Redbuds (there were two in annoying places so I cut them down). Box Elder’s fruit/seeds are much larger than the other Maple’s here. Umm… Now that you know, you can definitely tell there is A LOT of difference between Box Eder and Redbud. πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.